Co-Signing Your Way To A 1099C
Practicing Consumer Bankruptcy Law is very interesting work. Usually, I get to tell bankruptcy clients good news. Sometimes, I have to deliver bad news about their bankruptcy cases. In a recent case, a young man purchased his first home several years ago, and naturally, the value of the home has dropped significantly. He tried modification and was turned down flat (The mortgage is held by a securitized trust). That wasn't the bad part.
The bad part, as you can tell from the title is that he had his Grandfather co-sign for the loan. So, during the course of the bankruptcy when this young man couldn't get the lender to modify, he asked me: Can I short sale the property, and if so, what will happen to me, and what will happen to my Grandfather? These are both excellent questions.
Here is my advice: Yes, as an option, you can do a short sale. Of course, since you are in a Chapter 13, we will need the Judge's permission, and I will have to file a motion with the Court to allow same, but that is not a problem. I don't believe that the Judge will require any additional items from you other than a signed contract. With regard to the deficiency and you, the answer is simple, your debt will be included in the bankruptcy and you will ultimately receive your discharge, so, no problem.
The problem is: How will a short sale on your primary residence hurt you or hurt your grandfather? As to your grandfather, we have to look at a whole new set of issues. Since this property is not his primary residence, any deficiency that is still owed to the lender will have to be dealt with. This can come in two forms: First, they can pursue him for a deficiency balance. In other words, they can sue him for the remaining balance owed on the promissory note. As I have explained in the past, it's kind of like having two fish on a hook and one gets away. The lender still has one fish to reel in (Grandpa)
When the lender wins the lawsuit, they could go after his non-exempt assets. Alternatively, the lender could just issue him a 1099C cancellation of debt. If the lender takes the second option, your grandfather would have to deal with the IRS. As such, I would advise him to see a CPA for tax advice on how to combat this issue.
All and all, it is not fun to have to explain this to someone who took a risk on purchasing a first home and then sat back and watched his investment disappear as the Southwest Florida real estate market crumbled to the ground.
Now, I just hope the relationship doesn't crumble as well.
I apologize for the depressing blog, but this is something that you need to know and need to prevent in the future. When you take a risk, you want to do it on your own so that you don't jeopardize anyone else's future. It is never worth that risk.
This post was submitted by Carmen Dellutri, Esq., founder of The Dellutri Law Group, P.A. Currently, the firm has offices in Port Charlotte, Fort Myers, Naples and Sarasota. Mr. Dellutri also sits on the Board of American Board of Certification. Mr. Dellutri is also one of the founders of the Bankruptcy Law Network, Debt Law Network, Credit Law Network, and Mortgage Law Network. Mr. Dellutri also writes for the firm's personal injury litigation blog, www.faircreditreportingactblog.com and www.fairdebtcollectionpracticesactblog.com, and the firm's mortgage modification blog.
